BlazeDS and LCDS Feature difference

Following are the differences between LCDS and BlazeDS in terms of features. For more details on the features, please visit http://www.adobe.com/products/livecycle/dataservices/features.html :) - Indicates the feature is available

Features BlazeDS LCDS
Data management Services    
Client-Server synchronization   :)
Conflict resolution   :)
Data paging   :)
SQL adapter  
:)
Hibernate adapter  
:)
Document Services    
LiveCycle remoting   :)
RIA-to-PDF conversion   :)
Enterprise-Class Flex application services    
Data access/remoting
:)
:)
Proxy service
:)
:)
Automated testing support  
:)
Software clustering :)
:)
Web tier compiler  
:)
Enterprise Integration    
WSRP generation  
:)
Ajax data services :)
:)
Flex-Ajax bridge :)
:)
Runtime configuration
:)
:)
Open adapter architecture :)
:)
JMS adapter
:)
:)
Server-side component framework integration :)
:)
ColdFusion integration  
:)
Offline Application Support    
Offline data cache  
:)
Local message queuing  
:)
Real - Time Data    
Publish and Subscribe messaging
:)
:)
Real -time data quality of service  
:)
RTMP tunneling  
:)

19 Responses to “BlazeDS and LCDS Feature difference”

  1. Rich Tretola Says:

    Can you give your opinions on concurrent users? The article I read at http://flexblog.faratasystems.com/?p=277 said there was a major difference in the number of concurrent users that BlazeDS would support vs LiveCycleDS.

  2. EverythingFlex » Blog Archive » BlazeDS vs LiveCycleDS Says:

    [...] is a nice post for those of you who are trying to compare BlazeDS to [...]

  3. Top Posts « Democracia LTDA Says:

    [...] BlazeDS and LCDS Feature difference Following are the differences between LCDS and BlazeDS in terms of features. For more details on the features, please […] [...]

  4. Sujit Reddy G Says:

    Hi Tretola,

    The difference in the scalability is because the BlazeDS is using the web server sockets and there is a limitation on the number of active connections a web server can have at a point of time. Even the browser has limitation on the number of active sockets. :)

  5. Sujit Reddy G Says:

    Click here for details on BlazeDS and LCDS performace difference

  6. BeauScott.com » Blog Archive » BlazeDS RC1 Says:

    [...] Sujit Reddy G has put together a good side-by-side comparison of the two. Posted by Beau Filed in Adobe AIR & Flex, Development [...]

  7. Kevin Says:

    Are you sure that RTMP is supported with BlazeDS? I downloaded blazeds_b1_121307 and blazeds_b1_020108 and cannot find any references to supporting RTMP at all. Your list seems to indicate it is supported, just not RTMP/T.

  8. Kevin Says:

    Quick Followup. The official word from Adobe on BlazeDS and RTMP is :

    What capabilities are being released as open source?
    Adobe is contributing the core and proven Java remoting and HTTP-based publish and subscribe messaging technologies to the community under LGPL v3.

    This is a long way to say no. RTMP is not HTTP-based so it is not supported in BlazeDS.

  9. Sujit Reddy G Says:

    Hi Kevin,
    RTMP is not supported in BlazeDS. Please let me know Which feature in the list indicates that RTMP is supported by BlazeDS.

  10. Kevin Says:

    Sure. They way I read the “Real - Time Data” section under Blaze DS has two smileys for “Publish and Subscribe messaging” and “Real -time data quality of service”. I think the term “Real Time” led me to believe this was publish and subscribe and qos over true full duplex / non-polling channels (i.e. RTMP).

    I can see how you might argue that “Real Time” can be done w/o RTMP (like with long polling) but I think the subtlety there (and the fact that Adobe doesn’t really come out and say “no RTMP in Blaze) threw me off.

    Your list is great (thanks) but I think it might be clearer to indicate somewhere that LCDS has RTMP and BlazeDS does not.

  11. Sujit Reddy G Says:

    Kevin, thanks for the suggestion :) I will update my blog to reflect that. :)

  12. João Fernandes Says:

    Sujit,

    you say that webtier compiled is available within BlazeDS but in the current build it doesn’t seem to provide one.

  13. Sujit Reddy G Says:

    Fernandes,
    Yes, the webtier compiler is not available with BlazeDS. But you can still use the webtier compilation feature by downloading the installer from the URL below. As the feature can be used even without LCDS, i did indicate that webtier compilation (as a feature) is possible using BlazeDS.
    http://labs.adobe.com/wiki/index.php/Flex_Module_for_Apache_and_IIS

  14. Sujit Reddy G Says:

    Hi all,

    I have updated the table displaying the differences between BlazeDS and LCDS.

  15. Sujit Reddy G Says:

    Hi all,

    Visit the URL below for BlazeDS feature list
    http://opensource.adobe.com/wiki/display/blazeds/Features

  16. Pingback posted Says:

    free car quotes

    [...] simply the best post I’ve read in years! [...]

  17. LiveCycle DS vs. LiveCycle ES - clearing up the confusion « Greg Wilson’s Ramblings Says:

    [...] Gurrala, a fellow Adobe technical evangelist, does a great job summarizes the differences on his blog. For many developers, this provides all that you need. However, if you are building large-scale [...]

  18. Data Push in Flex with Java, .NET, PHP, Python, Ruby and more… « FLEXing My Muscle Says:

    [...] the features include:a. Collaboration b. Publish-Subscribe Mechanism c. Conflict Management …much more, (check out this article for a feature comparison between LCDS & [...]

  19. agimatec » Blog Archive » Adobe Flex 3 Roadshow Says:

    [...] die mehr Performance versprechen und eine ganze Menge zusätzlicher Features mit sich bringen (ein Vergleich). Der Vortrag zielte dabei etwas an BlazeDS vorbei und hob den Mehrwert der Lösung hervor. Über [...]

Leave a Reply